Smart and Stupid Conversations About MFA Programs

Via Racialicious, I just stumbled upon the blog of writer Danielle Evans, who attended the Writers’ Workshop and is currently teaching in the MFA program at American University, my alama mater. Danielle has written two excellent posts–Stupid Conversations About MFA Programs, and Smart Conversations About MFA Programs–where she discusses both lazy, unfounded criticisms of MFA programs (e.g., writers should be “living” instead of being sheltered by MFA programs) , and legitimate criticisms of MFA programs, including this one:

We should be able to talk about both privilege within MFA programs and privilege that MFA programs grant attendants in the world at large. In workshop, I have seen women get talked over by men with louder voices, people of color pegged as militant for fairly pointing out a racist element in a story, even if they are echoing a critique made by white students, men praised for their empathy and ability to channel women’s voices in stories that would be dismissed as chick lit if they were turned in by female writers. More often though, I’ve seen a sort of benign neglect of work that gets pegged as “exotic,” – because of the author or characters’ class or ethnic background. I’ve seen people be very hands off on stories that needed a lot of work, because they weren’t quite sure what to do with them. It can be hard to get critical feedback from people who lack familiarity with the world you’re writing about.

I’m not in a place, obviously, to talk about MFA programs in this way–give me a few months, after I’ve, you know, started mine. But the discussion of privilege in workshops is something that has interested me since undergrad–something to which my roommates who observed me coming home from fiction workshops seething with anger/breathing fire* can attest–and I can’t help but be (morbidly) curious about how privilege plays out in my classes at Iowa, and talking with others about it. Look my own observations on this same topic, starting in September.

(Danielle Evans’ collection of short stories, Before You Suffocate Your Own Fool Self, will be released on September 23rd, 2010, and can be pre-ordered here, here, here, or here.)

* Really.

One thought on “Smart and Stupid Conversations About MFA Programs

  1. Dave K

    Not on topic with the post, but cool to see you mention Racialicious. I know the girl who runs that, another Carmen. She and I went to college together. It’s been way too long since I read her blog or listened to her podcast, but I’ve always found it interesting when I’ve tuned in.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s